He's not surprised to hear that. Most people didn't. Not that he, a teacher, went around bragging about the sexual antics of his younger days. His train of thought completely derailed, though, when he watched Eli's lips sucking the ketchup from his fingers. And then it derailed again at the boy's comment.

Who wouldn't be flattered hearing that they're the only person someone's been interested it? And especially at his age. He's not typically the first one students fall for. Not when there are younger teachers to fantasize about. And yet, Eli only wanted him... for whatever reason. That made his heart stutter.

"So.. you've never...?"